Wednesday, March 7, 2012

Teachers rally against bills that undercut public education

UPDATE 3/7/12: Two bills SB498 and HB1130 are tinkering with teacher retirement. Teachers along with all state employees depend on the Virginia Retirement System. By Tuesday a House substitute for SB498 was rejected unanimously by the Senate. HB1130 was also rejected by the Senate Tuesday. They insisted on their substitute. It is now in conference and resolution is unclear. The language of both is confusing but Sen. Edwards aide helped clear it up. SB498 creates a hybrid defined benefit plan with a defined contribution component (401K) that would become effective for new employees after January 1, 2014. It would have a four-percent contribution by the employee and a one-percent contribution by the employer. For current employees it is optional to switch.

Law enforcement and the Virginia State Police are not part of VRS. To say that it will save money for the Commonwealth and localities in the long run can be debated. A reduction in cost-of-living increases is also in these bills.

Senator John Edwards was one of four Senators to vote against the HB1130, the House version of the bill and HB498. The odds of a bill making it out of this session are slim.


UPDATE 3/5/12 – 5:30 p.m.: SB498 is back to the Senate. It is the watered down version of the House bill. HB1130 would have asked state employees and localities to pay more into the Virginia Retirement System’s defined benefit plan and would have created a 401K type retirement hybrid plan. SB498 passed the House with a substitute Monday that would reduce the maximum cost-of-living increase from five percent to three percent for employees who by January 1, 2013 are no more than five years from retirement or retired already. The bill has been tossed back to the Senate.


Richmond legislators are shortchanging public schools again this year said a group of 150 teachers at a rally held Saturday at the Martin Luther King, Jr. monument. “If you’re for it – fund it,” they chanted. The VEA will present petitions to legislators today.

Sonya Meekins, a Giles County Special Education teacher and Virginia Education Association board member railed on the politicians. They spent no time in a classroom yet make decisions that negatively effect children’s education she said.

Leanne Worley from Franklin County said that Virginia’s public schools ranked fourth in the nation according to the Education Week Annual Quality Counts report. This, said Worley, was in spite of the obstacles and underfunding by the General Assembly.

Among the bills the VEA was opposing is HB576 that does away with continuing contracts and initiates yearly evaluations based partly on student progress. When schools are forced to reduce teacher staff due to budget cuts seniority could be bypassed in lieu of subjective performance reviews.

Teachers gather at Martin Luther King, Jr. monument for a "Wake Up Call for Education" rally.

Republican Richard “Dickie” Bell of Staunton sponsored the bill. Bell a former schoolteacher claimed that teachers should function as businesses and become “results-oriented.” Worley called on teachers to “shout down” delegates like Dickie Bell. Teaching is a profession.

Worley called the current budget proposal a “bait-and-switch” touted by the governor as increased funding for public schools. The actual result is a 4.7 percent reduction per pupil compared to 2007 said Worley. “It’s 2012 and costs are higher and we have more students.”

She praised the taxation and additional revenue for schools that will come from a sales tax on goods sold by Amazon in Virginia – “but why stop there.” Many corporations are paying no tax at all she claimed. “It’s time to mobilize – it’s not too late,” she said.

Senator John Edwards

Roanoke State Senator John Edwards told the teachers that “these last couple years we’ve had a legislature and a governor who’s the least supportive of public education of any governor in memory.”

HB1130 would ask state employees and localities to pay more into the Virginia Retirement System’s defined benefit plan and would create a 401K type retirement plan. Employees would pay 2% and the employer (localities) would pay 1% into the defined benefit plan. Optionally employees could contribute up to 4% which than could be matched by another 2.5 % from the employer. Maximum contributions to the defined contribution plan in the bill are 6% from the employee and 3.5% from the employer, for a total of 9.5%. The plan would take effect January of 2014.

Mandating localities to contribute more to VRS would eat up any additional funding from the General Assembly and than some. Senator John Edwards was one of four Senators to vote against the House version of the bill.

Thomas Ryder Roanoke County elementary teacher and VEA District 4 Vice Chair said that the pension benefit changes were a promise broken. Ryder praised the Senate for rejecting the budgets.

The VEA says there is another slippery slop for public education. HB321 exempts 70 percent of a corporation’s charitable contribution it offers in the form of scholarships to low to moderate income children so they can attend private schools. The VEA calls these “scholarships” just another name for vouchers. The cap per year for the state is $25 million and the tax credits sunset in 2017. “That’s not supporting public education,” said Sen. Edwards.

Thomas Ryder calls on teachers to "trash bad ideas for education."

Any slippage to private schools from public schools reduces enrollment numbers and funding to the locality that still must maintain fixed costs. HB321 passed the Senate 20-20 with votes falling along party lines. Lt. Governor Bill Bolling cast the tie-breaking vote.

At one point Virginia was ranked 3rd in the nation in student/teacher ratio now we rank 41st Edwards said. Ryder bluntly called it “the trashing of our public school system.”

Virginia teachers are paid $7000 less than the national average. “We’re in the bottom of the country,” said Sen. Edwards. In the past the Senate held the line on public education cuts. “We not only said ‘no’ but we said ‘hell no’”, said Sen. Edwards.

It is a wakeup call for education said the teachers.

Posted By Valerie Garner

Categories: Education, Politics, State Politics

Tags: , , ,


No Comments

Comments are not moderated. Notify any abuse at put ABUSE in the subject and the offensive post.

Leave a Reply